How to evaluate articles?
Published:
Personally, I evaluate my own or others’ articles from the following five aspects:
| Story | A hot topic in society？ Novelty of the story. |
| Model | Is the formulation general？ Is the model too complicated with too many factors? Does the simplication grasp the keys of the problem? |
| Methodology | How to solve the problem? Is it a noval approach? LP, dynamic stochastic control or mechanism design? Or an empirical study? |
| Math | Is it a hard problem? |
| Insight | Propose an algorithm（bound, complexity)? Simple and beautiful mathematical results? Counterintuive findings? |